demonstrations:three_polarizing_filters
Three Polarizing Filters
Materials: ★★☆ Available in most school laboratories or specialist stores
Difficulty: ★☆☆ Can be easily done by most teenagers
Safety: ★☆☆ Minimal safety procedures required
Categories: Electromagnetic Spectrum and Waves, Light
Alternative titles: Crossed Polarizers with 45° Insert
Summary
This demonstration shows that two crossed polarizers block all light, but inserting a third polarizer at 45° between them transmits light - an effect explained by polarization, state preparation, and superposition. It offers an accessible, visual introduction to quantum ideas using classical optics.
Procedure
- Gather two identical linear polarizing sheets (A and B), a third sheet (C), a bright, diffuse light source or projector, and a sheet of white paper as a screen.
- Hold A in front of the light and observe that transmitted light is dimmer (unpolarized → linearly polarized).
- Place B directly behind A with its axis parallel to A. Rotate B to find maximum transmission when axes are aligned.
- Rotate B to 90° relative to A (crossed). Show that transmission drops nearly to zero.
- Insert C between A and B with its transmission axis at ~45° to both. Observe that light now passes through the stack A–C–B, despite A and B being crossed.
- Swap the order (e.g., B–C–A) and repeat. Emphasize that the middle polarizer “prepares” a new polarization state that has components along the final analyzer’s axis.
Links
Three polarizing filters: a simple demo of a creepy quantum effect - Orion Lawlor:
3 Polarizing Filters - UMD Physics Videos!:
Variations
- Use multiple intermediate polarizers at small angle steps to increase transmitted light through initially crossed polarizers.
- Replace the 45° sheet with different angles (15°, 30°, 60°) and compare brightness.
- Demonstrate polarization by reflection: view glare off a water tray through a rotatable polarizer, then relate to the filter axes used above.
Safety Precautions
- Do not look directly into bright lamps or projectors; use a screen and indirect viewing.
- Keep polarizing films away from hot projector vents to avoid warping.
- Handle crystals and glass carefully to prevent cuts or chips.
Questions to Consider
- Why do crossed polarizers with no intermediate sheet block nearly all light? (Their transmission axes are perpendicular, so a state prepared by the first has zero component along the second.)
- How does the 45° sheet restore transmission between crossed polarizers? (It prepares a new linear state with nonzero components along both the first and the last axes; each stage transmits the component parallel to its axis.)
- What does this teach about “state preparation” and “measurement”? (Each polarizer both measures the incoming polarization and prepares the outgoing state aligned with its axis.)
- Would two photons ever interfere with one another in this setup? (No; the observed effects follow from each photon’s polarization state components and Malus’ law, not photon–photon interference.)