Rubens Tube
Materials: ★★★ Requires materials not commonly found in school laboratories
Difficulty: ★★☆ Can be done by science teachers
Safety: ★★☆ Some safety precautions required to perform safely
Categories: Heat, Sound
Alternative titles: Standing Wave Flame Tube
Summary
A Rubens tube is a long metal pipe with holes along its top, filled with propane and lit to produce flames. When sound waves are introduced through a speaker at one end, the flames reveal the standing wave pattern inside the tube, making sound waves visible as a dynamic flame display.
Procedure
- Place the Rubens tube securely on stands with its mounts.
- Connect the propane tank to the tube using the hose and fitting.
- Position the speaker so it aligns with the silicone membrane at one end of the tube without touching it.
- Attach the speaker to an amplifier or function generator using cables.
- Open the propane valve and allow gas to flow into the tube.
- Light the holes along the tube to create a row of flames, adjusting height with the valve.
- Turn on the frequency generator and gradually change the frequency.
- Observe how the flames rise and fall in patterns that match the standing waves inside the tube.
Links
Ruben's Tube - Jared Ficklin:
Ruben's Tube Theory - Outreach, Chem Eng, Univ of Utah:
📄 Rubens Tube - UCSC Physics Demonstration Room: https://ucscphysicsdemo.sites.ucsc.edu/physics-5b6b-demos/rubens-tube/
Variations
- Use different sound sources (music, voice, or sine waves) to compare flame patterns.
- Test tubes of different lengths or diameters to explore changes in resonance.
- Replace propane with another safe gas to see how flame patterns differ.
- Use slow-motion video to capture the movement of the flames in detail.
Safety Precautions
- Only operate in a well-ventilated area to avoid gas buildup.
- Always have a fire extinguisher and fire blanket nearby.
- Wear a fire-resistant lab coat and safety goggles.
- Ensure the tube is securely mounted before lighting.
- Never allow flames near the propane tank or hoses.
- Turn off gas supply immediately after the demonstration.
Questions to Consider
- Why do the flames rise higher at some points and lower at others? (They follow the pressure variations of the standing wave, with more gas escaping at antinodes.)
- Why are only odd harmonics observed in the tube? (Because it acts as a closed-end tube with a displacement node at one end and an antinode at the other.)
- How could the speed of sound in propane be determined using this setup? (By measuring flame spacing for a known frequency and applying the wave equation.)
- What would change if the tube were open at both ends? (Even harmonics would also appear, altering the standing wave patterns.)
