Inertia - Which String Breaks
Materials: ★★☆ Available in most school laboratories or specialist stores
Difficulty: ★☆☆ Can be easily done by most teenagers
Safety: ★☆☆ Minimal safety procedures required
Categories: Force, Motion
Alternative titles: Inertia of a stone, A quick pull is a break for Newton.
Summary
A heavy mass suspended by a top string has a string hanging from the bottom. A quick pull on the lower string causes it to snap due to the ball’s inertia, while a slow pull causes the top string to break because it the gravity of the mass add to the force.
Procedure
- Suspend a heavy mass from a sturdy support using a strong top string.
- Attach a string to the bottom of the ball so it hangs freely.
- Pull the lower strings very quickly with a sharp tug. Observe that the bottom string snaps because the ball’s inertia resists sudden motion.
- Retie and pull the bottom string very slowly and steadily. Observe that the top string breaks because it experiences greater tension than the bottom string in this case.
- Discuss the difference between the outcomes of quick versus slow pulls in terms of inertia and tension forces.
Links
Inertia explained by breaking a string - PhyicsIsFun:
Inertia Demonstration. Which String Breaks? - PrerequisiteName:
📄 Inertia Ball Breaks String - UChicago Instructional Physics Laboratories: https://www.physlab-wiki.com/physicsdemos/mechanics/newtons_laws/inertia_ball_breaks_string
Variations
- Use weights of different masses to see how mass affects which string breaks.
- Attach a spring scale to measure the force applied during slow pulls.
Safety Precautions
- Ensure the weight is not too heavy for the support or strings, to avoid falling hazards.
- Use strong supports to prevent accidental collapse.
- Keep faces and hands clear of the path of snapping strings.
Questions to Consider
- Why does the bottom string break during a quick tug but the top string break during a slow pull?
- How does inertia explain the outcome of the quick pull?
- Why is the tension greater in the top string during a slow pull?
- How does the mass of the ball affect the results?
- Can you think of everyday examples where pulling quickly versus slowly makes a difference (e.g., pulling off a bandage, snapping a tablecloth)?