demonstrations:happy_and_sad_balls
Happy and Sad Balls
Materials: ★★★ Requires materials not commonly found in school laboratories
Difficulty: ★☆☆ Can be easily done by most teenagers
Safety: ★☆☆ Minimal safety procedures required
Categories: Energy, Force, Motion
Alternative titles: Elastic and Inelastic Collisions
Summary
This demonstration compares how different materials affect energy transfer in collisions. A "happy" ball made of neoprene rubber bounces high, showing an elastic collision, while a "sad" ball made of norbornene barely bounces, showing an inelastic collision.
Procedure
- Obtain a “happy” ball (neoprene rubber) and a “sad” ball (norbornene polymer).
- Hold both balls at the same height.
- Drop them simultaneously onto a hard surface.
- Observe that the happy ball bounces high while the sad ball barely bounces.
Links
Collisions Demo: Happy and Sad Balls - Physics Demos:
Happy & Sad Balls - SMU Physics:
📄 Happy & Sad Balls - SMU Physics: https://demos.smu.ca/demos/mechanics/139-happy-sad-balls
Variations
- Try dropping the balls from different heights to compare rebound behavior.
- Use additional balls made from other materials (e.g., steel, glass, plastic) to compare energy transfer.
- Roll the balls into a wall to observe horizontal collisions.
Safety Precautions
- If using heavy or very hard balls for comparison, caution is needed to prevent injury or damage.
Questions to Consider
- Why does the happy ball bounce higher than the sad ball? (Because less energy is lost to deformation and heat, making the collision more elastic.)
- What happens to the energy that doesn’t go into bouncing the sad ball? (It dissipates as heat, sound, and internal deformation of the material.)
- How does the coefficient of restitution describe these collisions? (It quantifies how much kinetic energy is conserved; a higher value means a more elastic collision.)
- Can a ball ever bounce higher than the height it was dropped from? (No, because that would require energy gain, which violates conservation of energy.)