demonstrations:foil_boat_vs_foil_ball_buoyancy
Foil Boat vs Foil Ball Buoyancy
Materials: ★☆☆ Easy to get from supermarket or hardware store
Difficulty: ★☆☆ Can be easily done by most teenagers
Safety: ★☆☆ Minimal safety procedures required
Categories: Density and Buoyancy
Alternative titles: Aluminum Foil Buoyancy Demonstration
Summary
A foil boat floats while a foil ball sinks because shape determines how much water is displaced. The foil boat’s open, wide form pushes aside more water, creating a buoyant force that balances its weight. The tightly packed foil ball displaces less water, so the buoyant force is too small to keep it afloat.
Procedure
- Tear two equal sheets of aluminum foil.
- Crumple one sheet tightly into a compact ball.
- Shape the other sheet into a shallow boat with raised edges.
- Fill a container with water.
- Place the foil ball and foil boat gently onto the water surface.
- Observe: the boat floats while the ball sinks.
Links
#SparkofScience: Buoyancy - The Franklin Institute:
Variations
- Hammer the ball into as dense a ball as possible.
- Try different sizes of foil sheets to see how mass and volume affect floating.
- Add coins one by one into the foil boat to test how much weight it can carry before sinking.
- Compare with other materials shaped as boats (plastic wrap, paper).
- Explore how reshaping the foil ball into a flatter disk changes its buoyancy.
Safety Precautions
- None provided.
Questions to Consider
- Why does the boat float even though it has the same mass as the ball?
- How does water displacement explain buoyant force?
- What role does density play in floating and sinking?
- How is this principle applied in real boats and ships?