demonstrations:black_vs_silver_can_cooling
Black vs Silver Can Cooling
Materials: ★★☆ Available in most school laboratories or specialist stores
Difficulty: ★☆☆ Can be easily done by most teenagers
Safety: ★★☆ Some safety precautions required to perform safely
Categories: Heat, The Atmosphere
Alternative titles: Two-Can Radiation
Summary
This demonstration shows how emissivity affects heat radiation by comparing the cooling rates of hot water in a black can versus a shiny silver can. The black can radiates heat more efficiently and cools faster than the silver can.
Procedure
- Boil water in a kettle.
- Fill both the black can and the silver can with boiling water.
- Cap each can and insert a thermometer (or thermocouple probe) through the cap.
- Record the starting temperatures of both cans.
- Monitor and record the temperatures at regular intervals as the cans cool.
- Compare cooling rates: the black can should cool more quickly due to higher emissivity.
Links
Black and Silver - Emitting Infrared Radiation - Physics Videos:
📄 Two-can Radiation - buphy.bu.edu: https://buphy.bu.edu/~duffy/thermo/4B40_40.html
Variations
- Try cans of other colors (white, red, blue) to compare their emissivity.
- Use painted surfaces versus unpainted metallic surfaces.
Safety Precautions
- Handle boiling water carefully to prevent burns.
- Use heat-resistant gloves or tongs when pouring water.
- Ensure thermometers or probes are properly secured to avoid spills.
Questions to Consider
- Why does the black can cool faster than the silver can? (Black surfaces have higher emissivity, so they radiate heat more efficiently.)
- Why does the silver can retain heat longer? (Shiny surfaces reflect radiation and have lower emissivity, so they emit heat more slowly.)
- How does this principle apply to everyday life? (For example, car colors affect heating and cooling, and space blankets use reflective surfaces to retain heat.)
- How does this experiment relate to Earth’s climate system? (Surfaces with different emissivity, such as ice versus land, affect how Earth radiates heat into space.)